Written by

Bernard Marr

Bernard Marr is a world-renowned futurist, influencer and thought leader in the fields of business and technology, with a passion for using technology for the good of humanity. He is a best-selling author of 20 books, writes a regular column for Forbes and advises and coaches many of the world’s best-known organisations. He has over 2 million social media followers, 1 million newsletter subscribers and was ranked by LinkedIn as one of the top 5 business influencers in the world and the No 1 influencer in the UK.

Bernard’s latest book is ‘Business Trends in Practice: The 25+ Trends That Are Redefining Organisations’

View Latest Book

Follow Me

Bernard Marr ist ein weltbekannter Futurist, Influencer und Vordenker in den Bereichen Wirtschaft und Technologie mit einer Leidenschaft für den Einsatz von Technologie zum Wohle der Menschheit. Er ist Bestsellerautor von 20 Büchern, schreibt eine regelmäßige Kolumne für Forbes und berät und coacht viele der weltweit bekanntesten Organisationen. Er hat über 2 Millionen Social-Media-Follower, 1 Million Newsletter-Abonnenten und wurde von LinkedIn als einer der Top-5-Business-Influencer der Welt und von Xing als Top Mind 2021 ausgezeichnet.

Bernards neueste Bücher sind ‘Künstliche Intelligenz im Unternehmen: Innovative Anwendungen in 50 Erfolgreichen Unternehmen’

View Latest Book

Follow Me

Why Performance Appraisals Are HR’s Most Hated Process

2 July 2021

Have you ever received a notice that your annual performance review was coming up and thought, “Oh, yes! I just love those!”

I’m guessing probably not. It’s pretty universally accepted that employees don’t look forward to performance reviews. There is the feeling of added “busy” work or homework to the regular task load, the stress of wondering how you will be graded in an arbitrary system on which your future success and salary relies, and the speculation about how managers and HR will fit them into a mandatory quota system.





What’s maybe less universally acknowledged is that HR professionals and even corporate leaders hate them too! A 2012 study showed that nearly half of the HR leaders polled didn’t believe performance reviews were a good indicator of actual performance, and The Washington Post cites another survey that suggests corporate leaders don’t put much faith in the process either.

 

The problem with performance reviews

They are not objective. If you were asked to review your closest friend at work, how would you rate him or her? How about the guy who is the biggest pain in your work day?

Despite our best intentions, most of us would have a very difficult time being objective when asked to review our peers. Yet asking employees to help review one another is a popular model for conducting performance reviews that can determine an employee’s future.

No matter how you slice it, performance reviews are inefficient, not objective, and dreaded by everyone— in most cases it is a simple annual form-filling exercise.

But worse than being tedious, they’re also blatantly wrong a good deal of the time, making them useless as well.

A report cited by the Post found that two-thirds of employees who received the highest scores on their performance reviews were not the highest performing employees. And according to the book, Get Rid of the Performance Review!, surveys show that employees receive wildly different ratings when reviewed by two different bosses.

I believe one reason performance reviews fail so dismally is that they focus too much on the past rather than the future. How many of us can recall exactly what we were doing or accomplishing six or 12 months ago? In addition, the process mostly critiques performance rather than celebrates successes, which can be terrible for morale.

 

Improving the process

The current ways of doing performance reviews are inherently flawed. Instead of simply completing a rating regime based on arbitrary ratings or oversimplified KPIs, true and regular discussions should take place to encourage each other that everyone is working towards the same goal.

Instead of focusing solely on past performance and meaningless metrics, performance reviews should be flipped to become more regular open two-way discussions about how things are going.

The discussion should be about the company strategy, department goals, and how individuals could help deliver them. It should focus on both celebrating the things that are going well and delivering the support or training required to address any issues.

But these sorts of discussions require higher levels of trust—from the corporation, that the process will work (here’s a hint: it will); from the managers, that employees will perform well without a carrot and stick approach; and from employees, that managers truly want their input and have their best interests at heart.

I believe most of the existing performance review processes are poison to employee engagement and morale in companies. Everyone knows they don’t work and still we keep on doing them. It is time to replace the most hated HR process with something more meaningful and ‘grown-up’. We need more regular, open and honest discussions instead of these forced, inefficient and simply useless corporate tick-box exercises that everyone hates.

Business Trends In Practice | Bernard Marr
Business Trends In Practice | Bernard Marr

Related Articles

Why Every Brand Must Create Immersive Experiences For Their Customers

Are we becoming less material? It certainly seems that way. Research shows that today’s consumers increasingly prioritize experiences over material goods[...]

C2C

Why Every Business Must Consider The Platform (or C2C) Trend

It’s where customers connect with other customers to communicate or trade goods/services, usually via an intermediary platform like Facebook, Uber or Etsy.[...]

How Will Manufacturing Companies Use The Metaverse?

Manufacturers are already using metaverse technology to speed up product design, train employees, and streamline processes. What is the future of manufacturing in the metaverse?[...]

Why Every Business Must Embrace Personalization And Micro-Moments

The successful brands of the future will be those that can identify customers’ needs in the moment, and respond to those needs with thoughtful, personalized solutions.[...]

Future Proof Your Business With AI In Products And Services

There’s really no escaping artificial intelligence (AI) and the Internet of Things (IoT). It seems pretty much anything can be made smart these days – and that goes for services as well as products.[...]

The 4 Biggest Future Trends In The Financial Sector

And our relationship with money – how we use it, who we trust to look after it, and how we as financial customers expect to be treated[...]

Stay up-to-date

  • Get updates straight to your inbox
  • Join my 1 million newsletter subscribers
  • Never miss any new content

Social Media

0
Followers
0
Followers
0
Followers
0
Subscribers
0
Followers
0
Subscribers
0
Yearly Views
0
Readers

Podcasts

View Podcasts