Performance management- the measurement trap (part 3)
2 July 2021
Performance Management and the limitations of measurement
Performance management relies on good performance measures. However, not everything can be measured to an extend that we would like. A great example to illustrate our measurement limitations is measuring human intelligence. The ‘measure’ we would traditionally use is IQ (Intelligence Quotient). However, the questions that arise are: What is intelligence? And what do IQ scores actually measure? Whereas the details of the answers to these questions are still subject to an ongoing debate, on the whole IQ tests focus on our analytical and mathematical reasoning. However, Dr. Howard Gardner, professor of education at Harvard University, has shown that there are multiple facets to our intelligence. His studies have identified eight different forms of intelligence – of which IQ only measures a small subset. The forms of intelligence identified by Gardner are linguistic intelligence (“word smart”), logical-mathematical intelligence (“number/reasoning smart”), interpersonal intelligence (“people smart”), bodily-kinesthetic intelligence (“body smart”), spatial intelligence (“picture smart”), musical intelligence (“music smart”), naturalist intelligence (“nature smart”) and intrapersonal intelligence (“self smart”). This suggests that someone can be classed as intelligent when he, for example, has great hand-eye coordination and awareness of space – and therefore becomes a great basketball or football player. Someone can have great emotional intelligence and therefore be able to connect with other people and become a great leader. Others might have great musical ability and become composers or musicians. All of these people wouldn’t necessary need a high score on an IQ test, since it only assesses linguistic and logical-mathematical skills.
The above example hopefully illustrates that measures in performance management systems cannot capture the entire truth when it comes to intangibles. However, they can indicate the level of performance. They are therefore indicators, rather then measures, and have to be treated as such.
When performance managements and performance measurement clash
Organizations who implement performance management fall into the measurement trap when they don’t link their indicators to the strategy of the organization and when they attempt to quantify the unquantifiable or measure everything that is easy to measure without focusing on the relevant and meaningful indicators in order to use them for strategic decision making and learning.
Related Articles
8 Simple Ways To Enhance Your Data Literacy Skills
We’re living through the fourth industrial revolution (or “Industry 4.0”), a revolution that’s defined by wave upon wave of new technologies that combine the physical and digital worlds.[...]
13 Easy Steps To Improve Your Critical Thinking Skills
With the sheer volume of information that we’re bombarded with on a daily basis – and with the pervasiveness of fake news and social media bubbles[...]
The Most In-Demand Technical Skills – And How To Develop Them
Think of technical skills, and you probably imagine something related to IT or technology – data science, maybe, or computer programming.[...]
12 Simple Ways To Boost Your Creativity
Creativity enables creative thinking (coming up with new ideas) and problem-solving (implementing ideas to make things better) – both skills that are highly attractive in the workplace.[...]
7 Easy Ways To Boost Your Digital Literacy
No industry will be left untouched by the wave of digital transformation that's taking place. Everyday tasks and communications will increasingly involve digital tools.[...]
10 Most Important Leadership Skills For The 21st Century Workplace (And How To Develop Them)
With the rise of the gig economy and with many companies adopting flatter, more flexible organizational structures, now is the perfect time to refocus on what good leadership looks like.[...]
Stay up-to-date
- Get updates straight to your inbox
- Join my 1 million newsletter subscribers
- Never miss any new content
Social Media